OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

Carlton · 01-14-2005, 09:10 AM

Misisca was a good HR,RBI man...but in the 20's...and yet he was only an all star 3 times, hence he was never considered the best 1B of the AL, much less baseball during his time. He was very one dimensional...moreso than his son Mo Misisca

Minzey, he only placed top 10 in triples...and those were out of whack. He was good player, not a HOFer

Kinnear on the other hand, was a good defensive 3b...losing the GG to Nonnewitz many times...and Nonnewitz was probably the best fielding 3b of TWB. He was also top ten in BB, doubles, SLG on a consistent basis.

Schwartz, despite John's malicious attack...was the catcher of the 20's and was better then his counterpart Harry Finley of the Yankees (who should be a VC vote)

01-14-2005, 09:10 AM	#7 (permalink)
Carlton Hall Of Famer Join Date: Mar 2002 Location: Troy, NY Posts: 2,561	Misisca was a good HR,RBI man...but in the 20's...and yet he was only an all star 3 times, hence he was never considered the best 1B of the AL, much less baseball during his time. He was very one dimensional...moreso than his son Mo Misisca Minzey, he only placed top 10 in triples...and those were out of whack. He was good player, not a HOFer Kinnear on the other hand, was a good defensive 3b...losing the GG to Nonnewitz many times...and Nonnewitz was probably the best fielding 3b of TWB. He was also top ten in BB, doubles, SLG on a consistent basis. Schwartz, despite John's malicious attack...was the catcher of the 20's and was better then his counterpart Harry Finley of the Yankees (who should be a VC vote) __________________ "Curt's a friend of mine," Glanville said. "We used to play video games together. He killed one of my characters one time. I never forgot that." Last edited by Carlton : 01-14-2005 at 09:12 AM.