Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Johnny Slick
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Joshv02
1992,
|
Maddux, Clemens, Kevin Appier. |
Ehh, they are all reasonable, but I can't see why you'd take Appier over him. You can make a reasonable argument either way.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Johnny Slick
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Joshv02
1994,
|
Maddux (actually you could split Maddux in 2 that year and I would put both half-Madduxes ahead of Moose),Clemens, David Cone. Steve Ontiveros had a better ERA+ that year but I wouldn't say I'd rather have him pitch a big game than Mussina. |
I don't see why Cone is better, and Ontiveros had 115 innings 4.4 SO per. Again, I can see a reasonable argument for Johnson and Sabs, though. It would be reasonable to say any of those 6 (or maybe 7) guys -- or, really, it would be reasonable to say any of the 4 (or maybe 5) after Clemens and Maddux.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Johnny Slick
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Joshv02
1995,
|
Maddux, Randy Johnson, Tim Wakefield (seriously, Wakefield was aces in 1995) |
Wakes had fewer SO and more BB. I can see someone claiming Nomo was better, tho. Again, it is reasonable to put Moose in this bunch.