Quote:
|
Originally Posted by sebastian0622
Maybe my standards for pitchers are a bit high? The general consensus here seems to be that Mussina and Smoltz should be in, then the line is drawn between Smoltz and Key (and closer to Smoltz than Key). On the other hand, I was thinking that Mussina is borderline and the line should be drawn right below him, with Smoltz not getting in if he retired tomorrow but instead needing a few more good years. Maybe I'm just being too picky given what is already in the Hall.
|
The problem generally isn't where people draw the line. It's how they establish how good pitchers (edit: I really should say 'players') are relative to that line.