From the players listed it would seem like you guys would love playing in an online league called Boys of Yesteryear. I have the following "favorites" on my team:
http://www.boysofyesteryear.com/
"Shoeless" Joe Jackson
Big Ed Walsh
John "Mugsy: McGraw
Sam "Wahoo Sam" Crawford
Smokey Joe Wood
Roger "Duke of Tralee" Bresnahan
Honus Wagner, Ty Cobb, Walter Johnson, Nap Lajoie, Chief Meyers, Christy Mathewson, Zack Wheat, Art Devlin, and Mike Donlin are all in the league putting great numbers. The mighty Ed Delahanty has retired and is in the Hall of Fame where he belongs!