Quote:
Originally Posted by Dagrims
For those voting "no" or "too close to call", did his last two seasons do anything to make you change your vote?
|
Darn, the poll is closed. I would have voted "no" because he's been a good pitcher but not great enough for the HoF. I note with satisfaction that OOTPB would agree with me; I believe the default is either 300 wins or 250 wins and a career ERA of under 3.50. He has neither. He's never won 20 in a season and never carried a team to a championship; perhaps if he had, we could bend the rules. Sorry, Mike, no ticket to Cooperstown unless you're a paying tourist like the rest of us.