OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post - CubbyFan23/haveband Roster Set Ratings Discussion

chriskelly · 06-27-2007, 01:47 PM

a few minor items on the yankees.

Posada should have a 1b fielding rating, although a low one.

AI starts Cairo vs RHP over Jeter. From looking at the ratings, I have no idea why!!

Abreau deserves a higher eye rating. it's 78, vs giambi's 101. Abreau has 120 bb / year, and should be as high as giambi.

At AAA, Shelley Duncan is underrated. he's near the leaders in AAA in HR and RBI, but his power potential is at 40. I'd think it should be around 60.

On the mets,
I think Glavine is rated too low. ERAs in the 3's the last 3 years, but his stuff is only 36 and he can't crack the rotation. I recomend stuff around 50.

Same for el'duque's control. 3:1 K:bb ratio, 41 bbs in 116 ip, pretty good, but control is at 49, not much higher than oliver perez, who is a bb every other ip. I'd move control up to 55.

Everything else looks great. nice job!!

06-27-2007, 01:47 PM	#72 (permalink)
chriskelly Minors (Triple A) Join Date: Oct 2003 Posts: 276	yankee / mets thoughts a few minor items on the yankees. Posada should have a 1b fielding rating, although a low one. AI starts Cairo vs RHP over Jeter. From looking at the ratings, I have no idea why!! Abreau deserves a higher eye rating. it's 78, vs giambi's 101. Abreau has 120 bb / year, and should be as high as giambi. At AAA, Shelley Duncan is underrated. he's near the leaders in AAA in HR and RBI, but his power potential is at 40. I'd think it should be around 60. On the mets, I think Glavine is rated too low. ERAs in the 3's the last 3 years, but his stuff is only 36 and he can't crack the rotation. I recomend stuff around 50. Same for el'duque's control. 3:1 K:bb ratio, 41 bbs in 116 ip, pretty good, but control is at 49, not much higher than oliver perez, who is a bb every other ip. I'd move control up to 55. Everything else looks great. nice job!!