I let the stats determine most of the inductions. But as in all leagues there are guys playing in the late 1800's that started too old to accumulate classic stats. Lots of guys that only played 8-15 years. Eventually they were voted in by the Veterans' Committee or Old Timer's Commission... guys like Mordecai Brown, Dave Bancroft, Earl Combs. What's common with a lot of these guys is their post season success.
It's just another guide to use when trying to make an objective decision on a subject that is subjective in its very nature. Popularity, relation with media, and the eventuality of steroids have been, and always will be in the minds of voters. As much info as possible is always helpful when you need to "tip" the balance one way or another.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Curtis
In what way would it help?
|