Need some help from the community, the following player is borderline for the HOF. I use the Bill James Hall of Fame Monitor as well as his Black Ink Test. This player is on the border and I can't decided whether he should get in or not, take a look:
ELMER STEELE
1906-1921
SP
Code:
Year/Team/League Age G GS W L SV ERA IP HA R ER HR BB K CG SHO WHIP BABIP VORP
1906 St. Louis (N) Cardinals 20 24 24 14 9 0 2.18 223.1 182 68 54 2 67 116 22 3 1.11 .264 31.4
1907 St. Louis - ML 21 36 36 24 12 0 2.08 325.0 291 104 75 4 49 121 30 4 1.05 .274 45.2
1908 St. Louis - ML 22 35 35 17 18 0 2.25 311.1 281 105 78 4 72 110 32 3 1.13 .271 33.1
1909 St. Louis - ML 23 39 39 21 16 0 1.91 362.1 321 113 77 4 52 131 34 3 1.03 .273 58.4
1910 St. Louis - ML 24 28 28 12 13 0 3.29 240.2 237 120 88 6 72 70 22 1 1.28 .275 17.8
1911 St. Louis - ML 25 22 18 6 12 0 3.33 146.0 153 82 54 4 44 54 14 0 1.35 .294 17.0
1912 St. Louis - ML 26 38 38 18 18 0 3.53 329.0 381 188 129 14 81 127 31 1 1.40 .318 40.5
1913 St. Louis - ML 27 36 36 14 22 0 3.18 305.2 292 156 108 5 91 120 31 2 1.25 .276 27.2
1914 St. Louis - ML 28 25 15 11 7 0 1.96 146.2 133 48 32 0 47 37 14 2 1.23 .268 32.2
1915 New York - ML 29 39 39 14 20 0 3.42 323.2 331 187 123 10 87 106 27 0 1.29 .282 4.6
1916 Chicago - ML 30 34 34 15 18 0 2.27 293.0 255 98 74 5 56 110 29 5 1.06 .257 53.7
1917 Detroit - ML 31 36 36 20 15 0 2.49 314.0 296 115 87 2 48 94 33 4 1.10 .269 45.2
1918 Detroit - ML 32 22 22 9 13 0 3.17 190.1 184 87 67 4 35 49 19 2 1.15 .270 13.0
1918 New York - ML 32 15 15 4 11 0 3.81 127.2 144 73 54 6 22 30 12 0 1.30 .306 0.9
1918 Total - ML 32 37 37 13 24 0 3.42 318.0 328 160 121 10 57 79 31 2 1.21 .285 13.9
1919 Chicago - ML 33 11 11 5 5 0 3.01 92.2 91 37 31 5 11 17 9 1 1.10 .255 14.2
1919 New York - ML 33 18 18 8 9 0 3.87 153.1 142 76 66 7 26 36 15 0 1.10 .255 7.3
1919 Total - ML 33 29 29 13 14 0 3.55 246.0 233 113 97 12 37 53 24 1 1.10 .255 21.5
1920 Chicago - ML 34 27 27 13 11 0 2.99 223.0 223 93 74 12 28 56 21 3 1.13 .263 50.8
1921 Chicago - ML 35 31 31 27 4 0 2.59 271.1 282 98 78 10 20 64 27 4 1.11 .275 88.5
Total ML 16 yrs. 516 502 252 233 0 2.77 4379.0 4219 1848 1349 104 908 1448 422 38 1.17 .276 581.0
Elmer Steele as the following highlights:
1906 NL Rookie of the Year
1907 Gold Glove @ P
1921 American League Most Outstanding Pitcher
HOF Monitor Score: 47.501 (average HoFer ~ 50)
HOF Black Ink Test: 33 (average HoFer ~ 27)