This is kind of like going to a MAC forum and asking people, "Mac or PC?"
Baseball Mogul is usually a good game (although I haven't played this years version). But it's pretty simple compared to OOTP. That's not nesassary a bad thing, as some people prefer it's simplicity compared to OOTP. But if want the deepest baseball sim on the market its ootp hands down. Also, the nice thing about OOTP is most of the advanced options can be toggled on/off, so it can be made to play as simple as you like. Last time I checked, Mogul doesn't let you
enable features to make it more in depth
