View Single Post
Old 06-16-2008, 02:05 PM   #421 (permalink)
Thunder
Hall Of Famer
 
Thunder's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Connecticut
Posts: 3,180
Quote:
Originally Posted by mh2365 View Post
Magallon is a 9-5 fighter who is not better than 85% of his weight class no matter how much you want to prop up Matt. The thing is he doesn't need propping up ... like I said

I don't remember when I saw him probably as filler on the March card with Andy Lee. But that is his 4th straight decision win so I'm questioning his power now.
I haven't tried to prop him up at all, he's a 22-year old who can have a future in the sport. I think I've given him the proper credit and no more.

There are 1091 active featherweights, so the cutoff for the 85th percentile is No. 165, the 80th percentile is 218. In a totally dispassionate analysis, I'd say the two guys he beat are somewhere in that neighborhood.

But, I don't think Matt is No. 49, that's probably too high. To me, you have to prove you're as good as a Top 50 guy to be in the Top 50 and he hasn't done that yet. Thus, the call to fight a Top 100 guy, which I'd hope would happen in the next year and then we'll know more.
__________________
A government of the people, by the people, and for the people has not perished from the Earth. ~ A person I won't name said this, but he proved the U.S. electorate is sick of baseless partisan attacks (but for reasons unknown, the only ones that don't seem to have gotten the message are the ones who lost out because of said attacks).
Thunder is offline   Reply With Quote