OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post - 1871 Replay

BaseballMan · 05-02-2002, 08:28 PM

1 may say they have to get 750 pts from my system.
But then agin there are players who are in the hall that only have 5 years or so if you just go by most encylopedias that start from 1876. They dont consider the National Association a true major league. Like George and Harry Wright.
I dont think a player should be weighed against players of 1990's but rather his peers.

Also thinking about it with only 3 players getting in a year i may have a few Candy Cummings, but they would still have to be the best player up to that point and after a while the modern players would outpoint them leaving them to the vetreans committee as a last shot.

I think it will be more fun than players going in cause i thought they desrved it or lowering the hof criteruer. Plus you get that contoversy of baseball like the does the Ozzie Smith type desrve to be in the hall.

Well anyways i figured it out and i should have 252 from the vetreans by 2002 and 348 from the regular committee making a total of 600.
I think thats pretty close to the hall. I may have to lower the regular to 2 players.

You may wanna start checking the rookies pretty good cause i know Christy Mathewson and Waddell come in as midle relievers.

Great reports so far and excellent league.
You ever thought of building a website and putting the results of your seasons there?

05-02-2002, 08:28 PM	#32 (permalink)
BaseballMan Hall Of Famer Join Date: Jan 2002 Posts: 3,535 Thanks: 8 Thanked 90x in 60 posts	1 may say they have to get 750 pts from my system. But then agin there are players who are in the hall that only have 5 years or so if you just go by most encylopedias that start from 1876. They dont consider the National Association a true major league. Like George and Harry Wright. I dont think a player should be weighed against players of 1990's but rather his peers. Also thinking about it with only 3 players getting in a year i may have a few Candy Cummings, but they would still have to be the best player up to that point and after a while the modern players would outpoint them leaving them to the vetreans committee as a last shot. I think it will be more fun than players going in cause i thought they desrved it or lowering the hof criteruer. Plus you get that contoversy of baseball like the does the Ozzie Smith type desrve to be in the hall. Well anyways i figured it out and i should have 252 from the vetreans by 2002 and 348 from the regular committee making a total of 600. I think thats pretty close to the hall. I may have to lower the regular to 2 players. You may wanna start checking the rookies pretty good cause i know Christy Mathewson and Waddell come in as midle relievers. Great reports so far and excellent league. You ever thought of building a website and putting the results of your seasons there?