Ethan is lazy so I am taking over the Hall of Fame ballot duties this season. This is going to be a HUGE ballot so I'm just going to list the player, their position, their ERA+/OPS+, and their best accomplishment (IMO). You can look up anything else you want by clicking on their player page. Those who do not receive 5% of the vote will drop to the Veterans Committee. If the ERA+ is "???" it means it is not listed in Cato meaning it is 107 or below.
10 vote maximum, anyone can vote. Go to it!
HITTERS (Position and Name - OPS+ - Best Accomplishment)
Old Ballot
OF Eckard Burlingame - 132 - 4 Rings
3B Julius Coltrane - 138 - 2 BOTY
OF and P Gene Lassiter - 131 - 336 HR
CF Sully McTeague - 138 - Retired 2nd in runs, 3rd in walks
OF Whitey Murphy - 136 - .360 BA
CF Milton Shifman - 145 - 3 BOTY
CF Bowler Channing - 133 - 5 Tool Player
C Eddie Deal - 123 - 7 Gold Gloves
3B Dick Deustch - 137 - Only player to win BOTY as a rookie
OF Andy Roepe - 123 - 1991 BB
New on Ballot
OF Daniel Houlihan - 139 - .365 BA, 6 time BOTY, 9 time All Star, 4 Gold Gloves, 3414 hits, 1535 RBI, 1542 runs
1B/OF John Fosdick - 131 – 6 time All Star, 2003 hits, 1152 RBI, 1267 RBI
OF Tippy Cavanaugh - 120 – 2462 hits, 1399 runs, 1081 RBI, 1277 BB
C Dub Breslin - 107 – 10 Gold Gloves
OF Mack Bolan - 157 – 3 time BOTY, 9 time All Star, .327 BA, 1445 runs, 1355 RBI
OF Arnold Colfax - 131 – 8 time All Star, 6 Gold Gloves, 3068 hits, 1504 RBI, 1799 runs
SS Brian Boru - 113 – 2971 hits, career 2B leader, 1741 RBI, 1779 runs
OF Marion Morrison - 135 – 2 time BOTY, 359 HR
OF Buster Brubaker - 130 – Died at war, .323 BA, 3196 hits, 1555 runs, 1745 RBI
SS Jesse Summers - 106 – 3087 hits, 1543 runs, 1216 RBI
OF Michael Bones - 121 - .332 BA, 3529 hits, 1773 runs, 1625 RBI, 2 time BOTY
3B Gil Greatrex - 119 – 2763 hits, 1590 runs, 1508 RBI, 1085 BB
OF Cal Dupree - 122 – ROTY and BOTY in same season, .327 BA
1B Dolph Schlitzer - 131 – 3 time WS winner
OF Guy Fontana - 122 – Career leader in HR and RBI
SS Willie Wozniak - 108 – 1522 BB, 1338 runs
2B Douglas Guthrie - 106 – .401 OBP, 3022 hits, 1712 runs, 583 SB, 1835 BB
C Baron von Heidelberg - 101 – 3 time WS winner
3B Dave Brunckhorst - 123 – 1802 runs, 1820 BB, 605 SB
1B Urban Gaylord - 117 – 288 HR, 1290 RBI, 6 Gold Gloves
PITCHERS (Name - ERA+ - Best Accomplishment)
Old Ballot
David Brent - 128 - 1922 WS MVP
Randall Flagg - 121 - 300 Wins
Tom Paladin - 124 - 320 Wins
Brewster Jennings - 108 - Most extreme stats (most games, losses, strikeouts, walks, and home runs allowed all time)
New to Ballot
J.P. Herring - 131 – 379 wins, career CG leader, 2 time POTY
Ed Schultz - 153 – 5 time POTY, 3341 K, 292 wins
Ed Rondthaler - 114 – 274 wins, great leader
Bill Blake - 131 – 2 time POTY, 312 wins
Paul Drumheller - 146 – 445 wins, 3171 K, 88 SHO, 6 time POTY, 8 time All Star
Thomas Huxley - ??? – 264 wins
Arthur Deck - 134 – 279 wins, 372 CG
Rocco Siffredi - 119 – 266 wins, 392 CG
Gary Braunbeck - 123 – 246 wins
Hiro Spiropolous - 133 – 209 wins, 2203 K
Joe Saint - 128 – 275 wins, 6 time All Star