View Single Post
Old 08-26-2009, 02:22 AM   #146 (permalink)
tpaine
Bat Boy
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 5
Thanks: 2
Thanked 0x in 0 posts
Source/Basis for Original PLC Player Ratings

Quote:
Originally Posted by Big Six View Post
I wanted to include several PCL legends in this dynasty story. Most of them played only a few hundred games in the AL or NL, at most, but went out West and enjoyed long, productive careers.

The first group of these players joined my dynasty at the beginning. I didn't put them all into the rookie draft, because they were slightly older than most of the rookies, and were already fairly established players by 1920.

One such player was outfielder Jigger Statz, who signed with the New York Yankees. As a 22-year-old rookie in 1920, Statz hit a solid .347 with a .418 OBP. He hit only one home run, but demonstrated lots of gap power--48 doubles, 11 triples.

Another outfielder, Ike Boone, alternated between RF and LF for the St. Louis Cardinals. Boone, 23, batted .334-7-92 and, like Statz, stroked a ton of doubles--47, along with 5 triples.

One younger star, OF Oscar "Ox" Eckhardt, entered the 1920 draft and was chosen in the second round by the Chicago White Sox. In 70 games, the Ox was very productive, turning in a .339-2-48 line with 28 doubles.

One pitcher, righthander Frank Shellenback, made his debut with the Hollywood Stars after the Stars took hiim in the third round of the rookie draft. Shellenback got hit hard, though, and didn't get much support from the cellar-dwelling Stars (4-10, 5.30).

All four of these players made the major leagues, with Eckhardt making the least impact and Statz, perhaps, the most. They were bona fide stars in the PCL, though, with thousands of base hits, hundreds of wins, and batting averages well in the .300s to their credit. I rated them to be about as good as a solid MLB player, perhaps an All-Star. I think it will be fun to see how they do in this alternative baseball universe.
I have been following the posts reporting this dynasty sim and find them and the concept to be fascinating. Thanks very much.

I could not tell from the posts, however, whether the ratings for original PCL players that you introduced towards the start of the sim - such as Ox Eckhardt, Jigger Statz, and Ike Boone -- were derived from their real life stats or whether they were created as fictional players whose names you changed for the sim. If they were based on real life stats, did you use the players' minor league stats or the stats generated in their brief major league careers. Judging from the sucess of these players during the successive seasons, I can't imagine that the ratings for these players were derived from MLB stats.

Any insights would be appreciated. Thanks for doing this sim and these posts.
tpaine is offline   Reply With Quote