[Left-handed Badger]

Well, to make things simple I would just put the 2 extras in the AL.

So, the way I ended up with just now.

AL East: New York, Boston, Baltimore, Toronto (reluctantly)
AL North: Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit, Minnesota
AL South: Kansas City, Texas, San Antonio, Tampa Bay
Al West: Anaheim, Oakland, Seattle, Portland

NL East: Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, New York, Washington
NL North: Chicago, St. Louis, Cinncinnati, Milwaukee
NL South: Atlanta, Florida, Houston, Colorado (really not happy with Col here)
NL West: Arizona, LA, San Diego, SF

Really Colorado is the only one that doesnt quite sit right. But, I couldnt think of nowhere else to put them. Unless, for division realignment and they'd probably just trade with San Antonio which would still live them in a South division.