|
Dean -
Hope all is well in your real world. Your work has been a big help in my Page uni (your Cooney recently got off the floor to stop your Weaver in a great slugfest), and there will be plenty more going forward.
(at the risk of repeating myself, the following is copied and pasted from another mod)
I'm a novice at rating fighters or tweaking ratings, and was wondering what you, as well as those reading, think of the Mayweather and Pacquiao ratings in the db. Given circumstances, it looks like this might be a good one for my 'Shoulda but Didna' thread, but I want to take a good look at the ratings before doing so.
Their welter ratings look pretty accurate, but I have a few areas I'm wondering about.
---Pacquiao has a hp of 8, while Mayweather is a 7. Floyd can crack when he wants to, as shown by the hook that floored Marquez, but rarely does. Is Pacquiao high enough, given the two knockdowns against Cotto? Is Floyd too high?
---Mayweather is also a 7 for aggressiveness and killer instinct. That's the same rating Sugar Ray Leonard had at welter, which seems odd. Floyd can be lowered to 6 in both categories without lowering his overall 13. For that matter, his hp can also be cut to 6, along with aggressiveness and killer instinct, without lowering the 13. I'm not sure that he's a 13 welter yet, based on what he's accomplished at 147, but that's probably another discussion.
I'm going to take a few days to consider any feedback (I'm also posting this on a couple other mod threads - identically, to save the time of trying to paraphrase myself) before simming and posting the fight.
Thanks,
BBB
|