View Single Post
Old 11-01-2003, 09:51 PM   #25 (permalink)
Eugene Church
Hall Of Famer
 
Eugene Church's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2002
Posts: 16,945
Thanked 96x in 50 posts
Sorry for the delay...I have played several more seasons...will soon begin 1907.

OOTPB players seem to develop in an inconsistent manner...and maybe this is the way it should be...if Ty Cobb hit .367 every year and Babe hit 54 homers each year, I would probably get bored with it. I have discovered that I prefer the career over the replay. It has more surprises and is less predictable.

The Passed Ball ratings seem to be close to the actual totals...nothing outrageous like OOTP4 where catchers would have 4-5 times the passed balls as their rating.

Following is a list of the first string catchers in my leagues averaged over 3 seasons:

GAMES....PB RATING...ACTUAL
102..............2............3
140..............7............7
126..............1............1
136..............8............11
101..............3............4
134..............4............7
125..............6............7
132..............9............7
115..............0............0 (only 1 passed ball in 3 seasons)
124..............1............0 (only 1 passed ball in 3 seasons)
102..............3............6
140..............10..........12

Over one season a player would sometimes have a higher total than his rating...but over 3 years they seemed to balance out.

I am very satisfied with the OOTP5 PB ratings.

Hope this helps.
Eugene Church is offline   Reply With Quote