Can someone explain this

[zekester91]

Just going to throw this out there but could the rating on the first page be how he ranks in AA, as compared to other pitchers in AA, he's a 3 1/2 star player, and on the second page is how he would rank if he was in the majors, right now he'd be a 1 1/2 star pitcher if you put him in the majors.

That is just my guess....

[playball335]

Maybe Markus can clarify this as this has bugged me as well, for quite some time. Hard to know what the "real" scouting ratings should be.

[aewin]

Originally Posted by Rabbott

From some testing of turning scouting off and on I found that the only bug here is that the rating that you get under the scouting page is the true rating as if you had no scouting on at all but all the other ratings are based on that scouts opinion which varies from scout to scout depending on what each scout favors and how good of a scout they are and what you have your scouting acuracy set to

so basicly looking at the ratings on the scouting page is almost cheating cause you see the true ratings not the scouts opinion

so it seems like this would be a minor fix

This seems consistent with what I have noticed in my scouts league - the rating on the scouting page is more reliable than the one on the profile page. Can a moderator replicate this and get it recorded as a bug please.

[Vinny P.]

Originally Posted by StyxNCa

Historically there have been several glaring, obvious things that have been overlooked in beta testing so it wouldn't be a shock if this is one.

Why don't you volunteer for testing?

[Markus Heinsohn]

Originally Posted by aewin

This seems consistent with what I have noticed in my scouts league - the rating on the scouting page is more reliable than the one on the profile page. Can a moderator replicate this and get it recorded as a bug please.

This was fixed in the last patch. I do not see any problems here... if you see differences, then it is because of the fact that the scouting report is old while the stars on the porifle are recalculated each day with the current league as baseline.

[Malleus Dei]

Originally Posted by Questdog

But then, you KNOW everything, which is even worse......

Not if you have ratings turned off too and are playing stats-only.

[TSmith1969]

Originally Posted by BMW

A new feature was added recently that let you switch between "Ratings relative to all players in league" and "Ratings relative to other players at your position."

Sometimes when you add a new feature like that, you forget to stick the new code in all the places it affects and miss one. Any idea if it's caused by that? It would be a bug, but it would be nice if it could be explained to the programmers.

I think one set of ratings are in Fahrenheit and the other are Celcius.