[JTSMOOTH]

Originally Posted by phenom

I've seen a couple guys have pretty fast ratings increases in OOTP X, but I'd say it really only happened with good coaches. Maybe that was coincidental, maybe it wasn't, but the ratings jump on this guy may be on the up-and-up.

How he throws 100mph and didn't have a fastball baffles me, though. ROIDS!!

I think it also depends on what the player development settings are at...On default, you probably don't see such a meteoric rise, but if the league has the settings on quick development, then its certainly possible.

[udbacker58]

Originally Posted by POKeefe

This starter is currently owned by the commish in my league iMLB. He did not make any edits to the guy at all. This is a league that started in 2009 and is in 2010. The weird name is because we have renaming of two draft picks every year.

Player Report for #9 Ben Roethlisberger

He started out without a fastball and also was a 10-9-8 I believe at first. Strasburg went 1, Ackley 2, and a CF named Brimble who looks like a true 5 tool stud went 3rd. At 5th I picked a guy who looks like Rickey Henderson 2.0 minus the power who has now been traded as part of a package for Kuo and Ervin Santana. Just figured I'd post this since our whole league is in shock.

Originally Posted by snnort

But now he has a fastball, in less than one season... and it's potential is 8 out of 10?

I'd like to see his development report on a weekly (or even monthly) basis. I don't buy it.

Originally Posted by SandMan

How did he get from S/M/C of 3/7/3 on 1/1/2010 to his current ratings? I have never seen such a rise of a young player. Had to be some editting going on.......

It all depends on the player development ratings. The guy I drafted in the USBA went from 5/6/4 before the season to 10/9/7 by September (this was before I became the commish for those of you who would doubt ).

And it's all relative when it comes to ratings anyway. In one league a 8/8/8 guy could be an ace, while in another league he'd be just a mid-rotation guy.

Though I've never really had the best SP in a league, I have had quite a few very, very good ones in the USBA but had to trade them away because we were small market at the time. Of the guys I once had in my rotation, but had to trade, they have accumulated a total of 837 wins, 16 All-Star appearances, and 4 Pitcher of the Year awards. None of those PotY awards came while they were with me, and only 5 of the All-Star appearances

[ingey1968]

lol. I was in the league and he Most certainly edited this guy. its one of the reasons i left.

Originally Posted by Sabermetric Baseball

Learning a new pitch the "natural" way is not going to jump a pitcher's Stuff rating from a 3 to a 9, though it can produce inconsequential increases.

Using the 10 point scale, I've never seen ratings jump by more than 2 points in OOTP X. Player development is pretty realistic.

Now, if you go into the Player Editor and change a pitch with all 0's to 160 (which I believe is the equivalent of an 8), the Stuff rating will indeed skyrocket.

[coljesep]

"This starter is currently owned by the commish in my league iMLB. He did not make any edits to the guy at all. This is a league that started in 2009 and is in 2010. The weird name is because we have renaming of two draft picks every year."

This is why I don't join leagues where the commish owns a team. I run an FPS league and I don't own a team. If I did I'd be honest in terms of cheating but I've learned in my 7 yrs of commish'ing that a Commish knows more than the owners, which puts the owners at a disadvantage even if they don't edit ratings.