[djday45]

Charley Mitchell

[djday45]

Jem Stewert

[djday45]

Tommy Chandler

[djday45]

George M Robinson

[djday45]

George Old Chocolate Godfrey

[djday45]

Jake Kilrain

[djday45]

John Donaldson

[BigBoyBrackey]

Enjoying this greatly (even if Professor Charles Hadley got lumped up by John L -- maybe he should rebound with a crossroads grudge match with Professor John Donaldson?).

Not to interrupt your flow, but was wondering if you've rated Gatti at his various weights. I'm putting together at least a couple fights for my fights-that-never-were thread and he's only rated at jr. welter in the game. Found a jr. lw rating here. Do those two seem relatively on the mark to you, or do they need to be Deaned?

thanks for all your good work ...

[djday45]

Arturo Gatti

[BigBoyBrackey]

Put your Arturo right to work against another master of the face-first defense, Bazooka Limon. I'd say you were right on the money. The round-by-round results, for those interested, can be seen here.

Thank you once again -- somehow, there's a certain life to your guys. However you do it, keep up the fine work.

[djday45]

Hey guys, sorry i have not posted awhile being busy arranging to get married and am hevily involved directing and acting in a production of "A Christmas Carol" which is in October.

Will try to post some ratings soon. Any particular requests of eras, divisions, groups of fighters or just individuals you want me to look at.

Dean

[Beno999]

Juan Manuel Marquez ? I'd love to see you break him down analytically.

[swampdragon]

I'm restarting yet again and just downloaded your creations. I'm looking forward to putting them to work, not to mention going through them to see the changes you've made. If you make any new ones for your replay, I hope you post them.

Anticipating more after real life quits interfering.

[BigBoyBrackey]

Dean -

Hope all is well in your real world. Your work has been a big help in my Page uni (your Cooney recently got off the floor to stop your Weaver in a great slugfest), and there will be plenty more going forward.

(at the risk of repeating myself, the following is copied and pasted from another mod)

I'm a novice at rating fighters or tweaking ratings, and was wondering what you, as well as those reading, think of the Mayweather and Pacquiao ratings in the db. Given circumstances, it looks like this might be a good one for my 'Shoulda but Didna' thread, but I want to take a good look at the ratings before doing so.

Their welter ratings look pretty accurate, but I have a few areas I'm wondering about.

---Pacquiao has a hp of 8, while Mayweather is a 7. Floyd can crack when he wants to, as shown by the hook that floored Marquez, but rarely does. Is Pacquiao high enough, given the two knockdowns against Cotto? Is Floyd too high?

---Mayweather is also a 7 for aggressiveness and killer instinct. That's the same rating Sugar Ray Leonard had at welter, which seems odd. Floyd can be lowered to 6 in both categories without lowering his overall 13. For that matter, his hp can also be cut to 6, along with aggressiveness and killer instinct, without lowering the 13. I'm not sure that he's a 13 welter yet, based on what he's accomplished at 147, but that's probably another discussion.

I'm going to take a few days to consider any feedback (I'm also posting this on a couple other mod threads - identically, to save the time of trying to paraphrase myself) before simming and posting the fight.

Thanks,
BBB