VideogameVagabond.com posted their review of OOTP 10. They had the following to say:

"The game is full of information and stats. So full, in fact, that you can tell the game was designed by a group of real baseball geeks – and anyone who knows anything about baseball will recognize that as a compliment, not a slam. This is a game that is definitely a labor of love by folks who deeply appreciate the sport they are honoring."