Diehard GameFAN released their review of OOTP 11. They gave OOTP a score of "INCREDIBLE GAME". In their review, they said, "Out of the Park Baseball 11 is another step in a better tomorrow for baseball simulators. The appeal is not as broad as it could be but Out of the Park has enough moxy, guts and talent to draw in those willing to give it a chance. OOTP 11 is probably the best baseball simulator/game on the market today. The game is mostly menus but OOTP focuses on all the things someone would want to do as a general manager of a baseball team (and then some). For any and every one that has dreamed of running a baseball team, OOTP is a wish fulfilled. The game is customizable, almost to a fault, and For 40 dollars, you could do so much worse."