Gaming Nexus released their review of OOTP 11, in which they gave OOTP their highest grade of "A", and said, "All-star athletes aren’t born at the top of their game. It takes years of practice, training and endurance to perfect the skills necessary for them to make it at the professional level. That is why veteran players command respect from their teammates and fans alike. They exude confidence when put under pressure and shine where it counts. Out of the Park Baseball 11 is like that veteran player; it performs well this season and improves upon last year’s iteration in a number of key ways."