The print magazine PC Gamer released a review of OOTP 11, giving it an 86 out of 100 in their August 2010 issue.

In the article, they said, "If you bookmark sites like Baseball Almanac and Baseball Reference, then OOTP 11 is a no-doubt, walk-off home run no-brainer to become a part of your game collection. For newcomers, this is your dad's baseball game. And if you are that dad, or fondly recall memories of times at the ballpark with a scorecard on your lap, then the deep, involved world of general managing your favorite franchise can end up sucking hours upon hours of involved strategizing over the diamond, the payroll, the drafts, the waiver wire, and the DL."

This issue is on magazine stands now, so check it out!