OOTP 16's Metacritic score is 91/100 (as of 10/17/15)
OOTP 16's "fantastic simulation engine can be relied upon for realistic results but some surprises as well."
Grade A: "Where else can you take control of a franchise and shape it however you want it to look?"
OOTP 16 "is in a class of its own."
86/100: "The game is addictive. It's fantastic."
"A game shouldn't be this close to perfect, but OOTP 16 is."
"I fell in love with Out Of The Park Baseball. It's fantastic," writes Kyle O'Connor, who gave OOTP 16 a 9/10 score.
"A true big bopper, and then some."
"As baseball nears the season's end, I find OOTP 16 more appealing than ever," writes Vince Morales.
4/5 stars: "Amazing"
9.1/10: "Out of the Park Baseball 16 remains the go-to sim for those who have a deep love of the sport."
"OOTP is one of the best simulations I've used."
"OOTP is a fantastic game for baseball fans."
"There is never a dull moment in OOTP 16."
OOTP 16 "is a very, very addictive game."
"Out of the Park Baseball wins again."
"OOTP is a terrific game, a lot of fun, and if you like baseball, you'll like playing it."
"Once this game gets its hooks into you, they'll stay there forever."
"This game is as real as it gets."
OOTP 16 "is as close as you can get to the real thing."
"This game is fantastic."
"The game truly allows you to make your league your own."
OOTP 16 "is the best General Manager sports video game, period."
OOTP 16 is the "ultimate armchair general manager."
"What was already solid became almost flawless." (Review is in French.)
8/10 (review is in Dutch)
Romanian language review
"New levels of unimaginable depth."
91/100: "The deeper you delve, the more not only your team comes to life, but the world around it."
"Out of the Park isn't the Football Manager of baseball sims, it's the Dwarf Fortress."
"OOTP 16 is the most realistic simulation game in the world."
"OOTP, without question, is the best sports sim I have ever played," writes Brandon Willilams.
"OOTP 16 continues the upward trajectory of baseball's most robust simulation game ... It is nirvana."
"You will love this game," writes Ian Riccaboni.
"We have the greatest gift ever given to baseball nerds right at our fingertips and it's called OOTP 16."
"For the money you spend on OOTP, you get far more than any other sports game."
They simmed a league of the Nationals teams from 2005-2014 and concluded: "Is Out of the Park 16 really cool? Yes."
"If you're already a baseball nerd and are looking to misplace a few hours, OOTP 16 is ideal."
"Brilliant sports sim."
OOTP 16 "has improved on an already stellar product."
"If you let it, Out of the Park Baseball will take over your life. And you won't even care."
8/10: "The depth and the features of OOTP 16 will keep you playing forever."
10/10: "In short, OOTP 16 is terrific."
"The best keeps getting better."
OOTP 16 is "the most in-depth, comprehensive professional baseball simulator available."
5 rosin bags out of 5!
"Forgive the pun, but OOTP 16 hits it, frankly, out of the park."
"OOTP Baseball 16 is the most detailed baseball experience," says Bleacher Boy, who gives it a 10/10 rating.
"OOTP lets you literally manage every aspect of the team you could dream of and THEN some."
German language review
"It is an exceptional game, as always!" 4.5/5 score (Review is in Spanish)
OOTP 16 is "a ridiculously detailed simulation," says Bryan Hoch.
100/100: "Out of the Park Baseball 16 is the gold standard of sports simulator games."
9/10: "This version may be the most refined, deep, and streamlined yet."
9.5/10: OOTP 16 "proves once again why it's the go-to series for baseball management simulators."
"I love Out of the Park Baseball 16. It's that simple," writes Billy Brost.
OOTP 16 allows you "to indulge almost any baseball fantasy."
"Out Of The Park Baseball 16 Looks Like A Home Run"
"Out of the Park 16 was an enjoyable game to play."
OOTP 16 "is an Editors' Choice award-winning PC sports game."
"You could play this game for years and STILL be surprised at the events that unfold in front of you."
OOTP 16 is "definitely the smartest entry in the series yet."
"In terms of depth of its management modes, The Show and other games of its ilk is a Fun With Dick and Jane book, while OOTP is a long Russian epic."
88/100: OOTP 16 is "great for baseball enthusiasts."
OOTP 16 "is the ideal baseball game."
OOTP 16 "once again proves to be the best baseball simulator on the market."
OOTP 16 is "a much deeper management simulation [than other games]."
OOTP 16 "is another solid entry in the series."
9.5/10: OOTP 16 "knocked it out of the stadium"
4/5: OOTP 16 "takes the already-insane amount of detail and depth for which the series is known and ratchets it up to the max."
"Good game, we played Football Manager and Championship Manager for Years. This is now at that level of depth and we love it." 4/5 score
"Out of the Park Baseball 16 is once again a can't-miss experience for any diehard baseball fan."
OOTP 16 "provides an unreal level of customization that has to be seen to be believed."
"This [season sim] just scratches the surface of what you can do on this game."
"OOTP 16 = instant addiction!"
9.5/10 (Italian language review)
8/10 (foreign language review)
Total number of reviews for OOTP 16 is 79
"International baseball, OHBABY!" says Bradley Woodrum at FanGraphs, adding: "As always: The game keeps itself fresh, constantly. Loved ones go neglected." His 27-minute review of OOTP 15 goes into much detail and gives the game a 98/100 (A+) score.
Gaming Nexus gives OOTP 15 a 9.5/10 rating and says: "Out of the Park 15 has once again not only raised the bar for baseball management simulators, but also set the standard for future installments."
"[OOTP 15 is] a very fun, highly addictive game," says Gaming Age, who score it an A-.
"Out of the Park Baseball is once again the holodeck of baseball," says Quarter to Three, which gives 5 out of 5 stars to OOTP 15.
XGN gives OOTP 15 a 9/10 score. (Review is in Dutch.)
"OOTP 15 is a must-buy baseball simulation," writes SkeptiSys.
"It is no exaggeration to say that OOTP 15 is everything you could want in a baseball simulation game. Go get it," says How Many Altuves?.
"In my opinion, this game is a solid 9 out of 10," From Forbes to Federal says of OOTP 15. "It’s a great baseball sim that keeps getting better."
The Good Phight gives v15 a 75/80 score and says, "I think if Chase Utley had gone into video game programming instead of baseball, he'd have invented something like OOTP."
"In OOTP, even the most minuscule aspect of the baseball universe is accounted for, in exactly the same way it would be in real life," says Off the Bench Baseball, who give OOTP 15 a 9.0/10 score.
Beyond the Box Score says: "In total, [OOTP 15] is a micro manager's dream."
"If you’ve never tried [OOTP] before, you’ll wonder where it’s been all of your life," says Virtual Sports Network, who give OOTP 15 a 100/100 score.
"OOTP 15 improves on the already spectacular franchise," says River Ave. Blues.
OOTP is a legitimate five-tool game, says Most Valuable Zobrist. "It's the Mike Trout of baseball simulation software. BUY IT."
Meanwhile, Sam Adams, a TV sports reporter in Spokane, WA, takes on the Mariners in OOTP 15 and writes: "If you're a baseball nut, buy it. If you're a stat freak, buy it. There are so many different ways to play this game ... Take it from a bleary-eyed fanatic who has played this game way too much already: be prepared to lose a lot of time to this game. But, hey, it sure beats watching the Mariners in real life!"
"If you're a stat junkie, or just a baseball fan in general, I highly recommend [OOTP 15]," writes James Malone at From the Rafters. He gives the game a 9.2/10 score.
Seattle Mariners Musings ponders a possible version of the team's 2014 season thanks to OOTP 15.
OOTP 15 "adds some fun features while still keeping OOTP the award-winning program it has been," says TribeCards.
"Out of the Park Developments continues to deliver the most immerse baseball simulation experience to date; nothing even comes close," says Kain27, who gave it a 9.2/10 score.
French site Facteur Geek gives OOTP 15 an 8.5/10 score.
"I am absolutely addicted to [OOTP 15]. It is awesome," says DunbarSnackbar (Jeff Sherrill) on YouTube.
"[OOTP 15] is tremendous, and tremendously fun, and if I can't be a general manager in real life, this is a fine alternative," says Pine Tar Press.
GamesReviews.com gives OOTP 15 a 9/10 score and says it is "undeniably the best yet."
Game Revolution gives OOTP 15 a 4/5 score and says "it's everything you could want if you're a deep fan of the sport."
OOTP 15 is a "game of staggering depth and infinite fun," says Motor City Bengals.
"From the front office, to transactions, to the actual game of baseball, [OOTP 15] covers it all," says Erisea Magazine.
OOTP 15 "is an incredibly detailed baseball simulation," says Adam Shaw at FoxNews.com.
GameSided gives OOTP 15 a 9.5/10 score and says "OOTP Developments truly knocks it out of the park."
"[OOTP 15 is] the most amazing and fascinating thing I've ever seen," writes Allen at Darkstation. He gives the game 4 out of 5 stars.
"Out of the Park is a great series, and one that gets better every year," writes Operation Sports, who gave OOTP 15 an 8.5/10 score.
Gaming Illustrated gives OOTP 15 a 90/100 score and observes that it "is quickly becoming the best baseball game on the market."
B for Bernie says OOTP 15 is "one of the best ways to really experience the challenges and activities of managerial and team-building positions."
411mania.com gives OOTP 15 an 8.5/10 score (good for an Elite Award) and says it's "a baseball simulation that's so authentic it can be a little bit breathtaking."
"Out of the Park Baseball 15 continues the tradition of what is without a doubt the best sports management franchise to tackle the game of baseball," says The Sports Medic.
OOTP 15 “strongly confirms its place as the best baseball management simulation on the market,” says Orioles Hangout.
"[OOTP 15] is so deep, so detailed, so realistic and so awesome in every way that it is easy to get into a game and see hours, days and weeks pass by," says Miller Park Drunk.
"OOTP is the best baseball simulator out there — hands down," says Pinstripe Pundits.
Hot Corner Harbor decides to test out OOTP 15's historical leagues option since the game "has long been my favorite simulator ... for simulating past hypotheticals."
Hall of Very Good gives OOTP 15 an A-, citing its "unlimited potential" and noting, "this game seems to have thought of absolutely everything."
"This game is perfect for fantasy hounds, armchair GMs, and baseball fans who think the offseason is going just a little too slowly," says Rockies Zingers.
"[OOTP 15] literally puts the entire baseball world at your fingertips," writes Crooked Scoreboard.
OOTP 15 "is now one of the most comprehensive, sophisticated, sports management sim games out there," says Jays Journal
"The customizations and all of the different ways that you can play the game are what make [OOTP 15] (and the series as a whole) really special," says SportsLogos.net.
OOTP 15 "is hands down the best baseball simulation series for the computer that I've ever played," says Cubs Den.
OOTP 15 "continues its legacy of being the most accurate Major League Baseball simulation game," writes Patrick Green at Pro Sports Extra.
"The beauty of OOTP is that nobody can tell you how to play. For $40, you decide what kind of game you're getting," Disciples of Uecker says in their review of OOTP 15.
Italian site The Shelter Network says of OOTP 15: "The best just got better."
"Out of the Park Baseball 15 proves that the OOTP series is still the reigning king of the genre," says The Warning Sign, which gives OOTP 15 a 9/10 score.
"OOTP Baseball 15 is by far the deepest baseball sim game I have ever seen," says Last Word on Sports.
"OOTP 15, like OOTP 14... is awesome," says The Baseball Continuum.
"I would literally set up a stand on the corner of a busy New York City intersection and peddle digital licenses to the public - the game is that good," says StanGraphs.
"You will fall in love with Out of the Park Baseball 15," says Serbian magazine Play!, who give it an 8.5/10 score.
Romanian site Nivelul2 gives OOTP 15 a 9.5/10 score. (Review is not in English.)
IGN gives OOTP 15 an 8.5/10 score and says it "stands proud in its spirit and in its dedication to the national pastime."
Gaming Trend: "This latest release introduces some new functions and improves on others, dipping their gold standard game in a coating of pure gaming platinum."
"An improvement on (near) perfection," says GM Games, who gave OOTP 15 a 98 out of 100 score.
"The latest edition, OOTP 15, further advances what I fell in love with in the earlier editions," writes Mauricio Rubio at Baseball Prospectus.
"This is about as perfect a simulation of baseball management there could ever be," says Kill Screen Daily.
"I would recommend [OOTP 15] to any serious baseball fan," says Side of Natitude.
Out of Eight throughly explores OOTP 15 in a 48-minute video review and says that "like in previous versions, Out of the Park continues to be the go-to baseball simulation."
"If you enjoy baseball history, enjoy baseball, or just would want to run your own team, OOTP is the game for you," says La Metropole Sports.
"Once you start, you find yourself further and further into the rabbit hole," Pinstripe Alley says of OOTP 15.
"There are so many options, so many features, so many ways to play, that you can’t go wrong with this game," says Bugs & Cranks.
Spanish language site Hu3br.com gives OOTP 15 a 9/10 score and says it is "still one of the best sports management games out there."
Value Over Replacement Grit puts OOTP 15 through its paces and declares: "If you want a true baseball management experience ... OOTP 15 is an addictive solution."
Diehard GameFAN takes a look at OOTP 15 and says it "is still, and always will be, a love letter to the national pastime of the United States of America."
"Previous releases [of OOTP] have been among the most impressively simulated and highly regarded sports management games ever released, and the new season's release doesn't disappoint," says Rock, Paper, Shotgun.
Laser Lemming takes a look at OOTP 15 and says it's "a more in-depth baseball experience than you get in MLB The Show."
"Out of the Park Baseball 15 gets me the closest I will ever be to running a Major League Baseball team, and that experience is worth every penny," writes Justin Jabs at Cubs Insider.
"[OOTP 15 is] the most addictive game I've ever played," says Bluebird Banter.
Astros County publishes an amusing real-time review of OOTP 15 and concludes: "If you let it, Out of the Park Baseball will take over your life. And you won't even care."
"[OOTP 15 is] the best video game you will ever play. Seriously, it's that good," writes Adam Czech at AllGreenBayPackers.com.
"OOTP 15 knocks it out of the park as expected," says The Gaming Gang, who bestow a 9.5/10 score.
"I'd recommend [OOTP 15] to any aspiring armchair GMs," writes Paul Hadsall at Random Baseball Stuff.
"Overall, [OOTP 15] is a grand slam of a game," The Chiefly says. They give it a 10/10 score.
"OOTP once again knocks it out of the park with OOTP 15," says Mill City Sports.
"OOTP 15 is another worthy addition to an already great gaming franchise," says Purple Row.
Dynasty Sports Empire observes: "This game will have you saying 'I'll simulate just one more game,' and before you know it, it's 3 AM."
"I strongly recommend this game to anyone who is a baseball fan," writes Ronda Bowen at Wining Wife.
Total number of reviews for OOTP 15 is 80